September’s Most-Loved Puzzles

Hey, Emilee here! September has wrapped up, and I thought it would be fun to take a look back at which puzzles really stood out over the past month. Normally, I just share this kind of thing on social media, but this time I wanted to expand it into a full blog so you can see the top 10 all in one place. I am an avid puzzler and LOVE seeing what other people are loving right now. I'm trying not to be tempted by these images, but it is going to be hard to resist! Anyways, let’s count them down from #10 to #1!

As you scroll through, let me know—did one of these just land on your wishlist?

#10. Halloween Witches – Vermont Christmas Company (1000 pieces)

This one has such a darker, moodier vibe compared to a lot of the bright fall puzzles, which might make it a little trickier to put together. But the golden glow in the windows and that teal sky break it up beautifully, making the image more doable. I’ve been gathering my own Halloween puzzles lately, so I’m not at all surprised to see some spooky ones creeping onto the list this month. Did you know the most popular puzzle from Vermont Christmas Company is actually for Halloween??

#9. Dinner at Grandma’s – MasterPieces (550 pieces)

I love the American Folk Art style from Bonnie White. If you’re a fan of Charles Wysocki puzzles, this is definitely another artist you’d enjoy. There are so many fun elements to work with here—the white house, red barn, a cozy cloudy sky, and even a horse-drawn carriage. This one feels very nostalgic, and I can easily picture myself puzzling it on a cozy fall weekend.

.

#8. Japanese Garden in Bloom – SunsOut (1000 pieces)

This one is so eye-catching that even when I was walking the shelves in the distribution center, it stopped me in my tracks! It’s such a stunning image. The best part is that it comes in both a 1000-piece and a 300-piece version, which is perfect if florals sometimes feel a little intimidating. Personally, it reminds me of when we lived in San Diego and visited the Japanese Friendship Garden—such a beautiful, peaceful scene to capture in puzzle form.

#7. Cactus Garden – Cobble Hill (1000 pieces)

Maybe I’m just scarred from the cactus nightmare at last year’s World Championship, but cacti in puzzles still make me a little nervous. So shout-out to all the brave puzzlers tackling this beast! The good news is that this image at least mixes things up with colorful flowers, birds, and different varieties of cacti, which helps break up the challenge. And of course, Cobble Hill’s great quality makes it all the more enjoyable once you dive in.

#6. Northern Lights – MasterPieces (550 pieces)

Looks like some people are already getting ready for winter! This is such a doable snowy scene that I’m casually adding it to my own wishlist. I can totally see myself puzzling this one on a dreary cold day, with a Karoscene lantern glowing nearby, the fireplace on, and of course—a hot cup of tea. The glowing sky, cabin, snowy trees, and shimmering water make it inviting without being overwhelming. Plus, there isn’t too much plain white, which makes it far more approachable than many winter puzzles.

Halfway through the list! Have you spotted a favorite yet?

#5. Autumn Harvest – Vermont Christmas Company (1000 pieces)

Did someone say squash? This puzzle is basically a celebration of gourds, pumpkins, and squash galore. It’s such a unique image, and I love the variety of colors woven through it. Honestly, there’s not much more to say—it’s pumpkins and squash, and that’s exactly what makes it so fun and perfectly seasonal for September puzzling.

#4. The Old Filling Station – MasterPieces (1000 pieces)

Here’s another classic Americana puzzle, this time by Art Poulin. The image features an old-timey gas station with a road full of classic cars lined up, waiting for the gas attendant. Poulin is considered one of America’s foremost folk artists, known for painting timeless scenes of inviting landscapes, and this puzzle is no exception. Personally, I love the whole scene—and I know I’d start with all those signs full of words before moving on to the rest.

#3. Mushroom Forest – GoodWay Puzzles (1000 pieces)

I actually posted about this one recently because it completely stopped me in my tracks. When you’re looking at puzzles every single day, sometimes I can feel a bit numb to certain images—even though I’d happily do them if they were in front of me. But this one, this one!! I LOVE it. The neon colors, the glowing fantasy world, the absolutely stunning artwork by Kimberly McGuinness—it’s all so magical. No surprise, this one is already on my wishlist.

#2. Harvest Street Party – MasterPieces (500 pieces)

By now it’s no secret that Americana folk art puzzles are popular, and when you pair that style with fall themes, it’s no surprise to see one land so high on the list. This is another Art Poulin puzzle, filled with pumpkins, festive details, and that small-town charm he’s so well known for. I love the attention to detail—it feels like every corner of the image has something new to spot. And while this one comes in a big 1200-piece size, I kept catching myself thinking how perfect a 500-piece version would be for a cool fall evening.

#1. Stained Glass Hummingbirds – GoodWay Puzzles (1000 pieces)

Woah! Another stunning image from GoodWay, and what a worthy puzzle for first place! So many puzzlers fell in love with this image, and it’s easy to see why. Peggy Collins is one of our top puzzle artists, and this design is absolutely a hit. Vibrant and enchanting, the Stained Glass Hummingbirds puzzle transports puzzlers into a mesmerizing world of nature’s beauty. The intricate stained-glass effect, glowing colors, and delicate hummingbirds surrounded by radiant floral elements make this puzzle feel both beautiful and different—truly deserving of the #1 spot for September.

That’s the Top 10 for September! I love seeing which puzzles the community gravitates toward each month—it’s always such an interesting mix of seasonal favorites and year-round gems. If you like the style of countdown, let me know!! I can make sure to do it again for future months.

Now it’s your turn: which of these puzzles would you most want on your table this fall? Drop your pick in the comments or tag me on social so I can see what made it onto your wishlist.